Names and identifying details in this case study have been changed to protect our client’s privacy.
Hugh did the hard thing. When his mortgage and bills got on top of him, he sold his property and paid off everything he owed. Soon after, his bank sent him a letter confirming the account was paid and closed.
Years later he applied for finance and was knocked back. There was a Westpac default for about $10,000 on his credit file, and a debt collector, Panthera Finance, now held the account.

A paid debt that wouldn’t go away
It’s a common shock. A default can stay on your file for five years even after you pay, and paying doesn’t wipe it. Hugh had a letter saying the account was closed, and he still couldn’t get a loan.
We asked Panthera Finance for the documents behind the listing, including the original credit contract. They didn’t hand over everything we asked for. Then they declined to remove the default.
Taking it to the ombudsman
So we lodged a complaint with the Australian Financial Complaints Authority. We set out how much financial strain Hugh was under around the time the account was listed. We also pressed, again, for the original contract.
Why it came off
Panthera Finance told us it would remove the default for two reasons: Hugh’s circumstances at the time he was listed, and the fact that it couldn’t produce the original contract we’d asked for. If a creditor can’t back up a listing with its own paperwork, it’s on very weak ground.
The result
We started on 16 May. The default was removed on 27 August, 103 days later. Hugh could finally put a debt he’d paid long ago behind him.
What this means for you
A refusal from a collector isn’t the end of the road. Ask for the documents, and if they won’t fix it, an external complaint often changes the conversation. Our credit repair lawyers handle ombudsman complaints like this one all the time.
This is a past matter. Names and identifying details have been changed to protect our client’s privacy.
Results depend on individual circumstances. Every credit file is different, and a past result doesn’t guarantee the outcome of your matter. This case study is general information, not legal advice.
Don’t spend another month stuck in Credit Prison. Call our credit repair lawyers on 1300 667 218 or book a 15-minute intro call at https://mycralawyers.com.au/15min-credit-repair-intro-call/ . If we think your chances are low, we’ll tell you straight.
MyCRA Lawyers | Australia-wide | 1300 667 218 | Contact form | Book a 15-minute intro call
Leave A Comment